Home › Identifying › How to tell asbestos from other building material

How to tell asbestos from other building material

By · Updated

Eyes and hands cannot settle it. Paperwork, position and age can move the odds a long way, though, and that is where to start.

You cannot tell asbestos apart from other material by sight, touch or sound. Fibre cement that contains asbestos and fibre cement that does not can be the same colour, the same thickness and the same pattern. Only a sample analysed by a NATA-accredited laboratory settles it. What you can do is collect clues that make “compatible with containing asbestos” more or less likely.

Start with what you already have on paper

The best evidence is often sitting in a drawer. Building approvals, renovation invoices, an old pre-purchase report or a builder’s specification can name the exact product used. A sheet described as a modern fibre cement board from after 2003 is a very different case from a vague note about “fibro lining, 1970s”.

No paperwork? Ask the neighbours or the previous owner. Estates built by one developer in one year tend to share the same cladding and roofing, so a straight answer from next door is worth having.

Age narrows the odds more than appearance does

Asbestos was phased out of fibre cement sheeting through the 1980s and banned outright in Australia on 31 December 2003. Material installed well before the mid-1980s is the most likely to be compatible with containing it. Material installed after 2003 is very unlikely to be.

The awkward middle is roughly the late 1980s to 2003. Some products in that window contained it and some did not, which is exactly why a date alone never closes the question. Treat that band as unknown, not as safe.

Markings can help, if you can read them without touching

Some products carry a manufacturer’s stamp or a printed batch mark on the back or the edge. You may see one from a hatch, a roof space or a gap that is already open. Photograph it from where you stand and use the brand name and product line to check the manufacturer’s own information or the federal regulator’s product database.

Do not turn a sheet over, lift an edge, snap a corner off or scrape paint away to look for a mark. Disturbing the material to read a label defeats the purpose. If the marking is not visible as things stand, it is not a clue you get to use.

The lookalikes that cause most false alarms

Plenty of harmless products look like the material people worry about. Modern fibre cement, compressed sheet, hardboard and some plasterboard products all get mistaken for old “fibro”. Profiled steel roofing is often taken for corrugated cement sheet from the ground.

The reverse mistake matters more. Something can look modern because it has been painted, patched or covered, and still be an older sheet underneath. Paint tells you nothing about what it covers.

Methods that do not work, and one you should never try

Tapping a wall for a certain sound proves nothing. Neither does the smell, the weight, or how the surface feels. Handheld gadgets sold as detectors do not identify asbestos through a wall either, as we explain in our piece on detectors and test kits.

Never cut, drill, sand or break a piece off to see what is inside. That is the one action that can turn a stable material into a problem, and it is exactly what a licensed professional is trained to avoid.

Three houses, three different readings

A 1962 weatherboard-and-fibro cottage with original flat sheet under the eaves ticks every box: the right era, a common product and a location where it was routinely used. Treat it as compatible with containing asbestos until a laboratory says otherwise.

A 1998 bathroom in the same house is harder. It sits in the unknown band, and the wet-area lining could be either. You want the invoice, or a sample, before anyone tiles over it or knocks a hole through it.

A 2012 extension with documented fibre cement cladding is the easy one. The date and the paperwork both point the same way, so you can stop worrying about that section and concentrate on the older parts. Each part of a house gets its own reading.

When the clues run out

If the paper trail, the age and the visible markings still leave you undecided, you have three sensible routes. You can leave the material alone and monitor it, have it sampled and analysed, or engage a licensed assessor for a written report. What an asbestos check actually covers sets out which of the three fits which situation.

For a single material in a single spot, our evidence check takes the age, location, appearance and condition you have and tells you which route makes sense. It does not say whether the material is asbestos. Nothing short of a laboratory can do that.

Frequently asked questions

Can you tell if something is asbestos just by looking at it?

No. Asbestos-containing sheet and asbestos-free sheet can look identical to the eye. Appearance, age and location can raise or lower the odds, but only a laboratory analysis of a sample gives an answer.

Is there a home test that shows whether a material contains asbestos?

Home kits do not analyse anything themselves. They are a way of posting a sample to a laboratory, and taking that sample can itself disturb the material, so it is usually better left to a licensed person.

Does a paint coat or a newer surface mean the material underneath is safe?

No. Paint and newer linings are often applied over older material without removing it, so a modern-looking surface says nothing about what sits behind it.

What is the safest thing to do with material I am unsure about?

Leave it intact and undisturbed, keep people and tools away from it, and decide whether it is worth having sampled or assessed before any renovation or repair work near it.

Sources

What this page explains is based on these official sources. If you check one and it does not match what you read here, send it to us and the article gets corrected.

Keep reading